Song Cover Image

Technically I Didn’t Steal the Horse

[Intro] [Spoken over barroom piano and a lazy fiddle. Narrator sounds completely confident in a terrible legal defense.] Your Honor, before we begin, I’d like to clarify one thing. I did not steal that horse. [Pause.] I merely left town on him. [Verse] [Fast country storytelling. Acoustic guitar, upright bass, brushed snare. Deliver every excuse like airtight logic.] Now yes, he belonged to a fellow named Dale, And yes, Dale was yelling while I hit the trail. But nobody said I could not take a ride, And technically Dale never caught me outside. The gate was unlocked, the saddle was near, The horse looked bored, I was fresh out of beer. He walked toward me first, that matters in court, I simply supported equestrian sport. [Pre-Chorus] [Fiddle answers each line. Narrator grows more defensive.] Was there a rope? Sure. Was it mine? Maybe. Did I cut the fence? [Pause.] That accusation is crazy. [Chorus] [Big saloon singalong. Add stomps, handclaps, and rowdy backing vocals.] Technically I didn’t steal the horse, I just changed his geographical course. No bill of sale, no written divorce, But technically I didn’t steal the horse. He chose the road, I held the reins, That’s just teamwork across the plains. Call it borrowing with no remorse, But technically I didn’t steal the horse. [Verse] [Add banjo. Story becomes obviously worse.] Now twelve miles south we encountered the law, I tipped my hat and said, “Evening, y’all.” They asked why the saddle said PROPERTY OF DALE, I said branding can sometimes be terribly stale. Then Dale showed up in a pickup truck, Yelling words I probably shouldn’t discuss. He said, “That’s my horse!” I said, “Prove he’s yours.” The horse yelled something. [Break] Objection. Hearsay, of course. [Chorus] [Full band. Background singers laugh between lines.] Technically I didn’t steal the horse, I just changed his geographical course. No bill of sale, no written divorce, But technically I didn’t steal the horse. He chose the road, I held the reins, That’s just teamwork across the plains. Call it borrowing with no remorse, But technically I didn’t steal the horse. [Bridge] [Drop to piano, bass, and narrator. Deliver like a lawyer presenting brilliant closing arguments.] Now the prosecution keeps saying “theft.” I prefer “departure with assets.” They say I crossed three county lines. Coincidence. They found Dale’s wallet in my coat. Unrelated. His watch in my boot. Circumstantial. And the note saying, “Thanks for the horse, idiot”? [Pause.] Clearly satire. [Build] [Snare rolls. Fiddle climbs. Narrator starts losing control.] I never sold him. I only took cash. I never fled town. I departed real fast. I never hid. I changed my name. And Dale being angry Doesn’t make me to blame! [Chorus] [Maximum honky tonk chaos. Full crowd shouting along.] Technically I didn’t steal the horse, I just changed his geographical course. The judge looks tired, Dale looks hoarse, But technically I didn’t steal the horse. Maybe I rode him through Tennessee, Maybe his owner disagrees. But words have meaning, check your source, And technically I didn’t steal the— [Break] [Band stops abruptly. Gavel slam.] [Spoken Word] Guilty? [Pause.] Well, that feels extremely interpretive. [Outro] [Fiddle plays a quick descending phrase as the narrator is apparently escorted away.] Your Honor! Can I at least keep the horse? [Hard stop.]