[Verse 1] I let the night ring twice Then I made it three Your name on my screen Like it still knows me My thumb froze up On the cracked-up glass Old sins in a row And they never pass [Pre-Chorus] One by one They start to breathe Say my name Like a broken key And I know What that means [Chorus] All my old lovers come back from hell (Call me in) All my old lovers come back from hell (Call me in) They know my heart by the way it fell (Call me in) All my old lovers come back from hell [Verse 2] There’s red on the snow At the edge of dawn A voicemail left From a voice long gone You said, “pick up now” Like you owned the line I swear I heard Your laugh in mine [Pre-Chorus] One by one They rise again Cold little flames In a dead-end wind And I know How this ends [Chorus] All my old lovers come back from hell (Call me in) All my old lovers come back from hell (Call me in) They know my heart by the way it fell (Call me in) All my old lovers come back from hell [Bridge] I should let it ring I should let it burn But every old ache Wants another turn So I answer slow With a shaking hand And the line goes deep Like a sinking stand [Final Chorus] All my old lovers come back from hell (Call me in) All my old lovers come back from hell (Call me in) They know my heart by the way it fell (Call me in) All my old lovers come back from hell (Call me in)
