Song Cover Image

I was there, but sadder I guess

I WAS THERE [Verse 1] The hairs on my arms stood up the first time I met you. No metaphor. No hindsight. Just my whole body knowing something before I did. And after that I was always a little bit yours. In step. My hand in yours. Trying to catch my breath while you were already halfway to the next thing. Kraven. Permission to say hell yeah. Coffee for Jen? Jack? Games everywhere. Ferries. Long walks. 0.5 photos where nobody looks good and somehow everybody does. Europe. Did Europe happen? Did any of it happen? Because sometimes I look back and it feels like I was standing right beside you the whole time and somehow I never entered the frame. ⸻ [Refrain] I was there. I know I was there. I can name the streets. I can name the jokes. I can tell you what you ordered and which way you turned and where your hand was in mine. I was there. So why does losing you feel so much like finding out I was invisible? ⸻ [Verse 2] Therapy keeps offering clean little explanations. You loved the idea of him. No. You loved the future you imagined with him. I couldn’t imagine a future with you. You were never still long enough to put one anywhere. You loved who you were with him. No. That would almost be easier. It was you. The stupid unfinished stories. The way you lit up at things. The chaos. The games. The running commentary. The parts of you that made no fucking sense. I loved the person. That is the problem. And maybe all that advice belongs to you instead. Maybe you loved how I made you feel. Wanted. Safe. Interesting. Chosen. Maybe I was dopamine with a pulse. Maybe I was useful until I wasn’t new. And I hate that sentence. I hate how possible it feels. ⸻ [Chorus] Because I thought love meant staying. Not forever. Just— staying long enough to finish the conversation. Staying through the panic. Staying when the nervous system starts calling somebody the enemy. Staying long enough to ask: what happened to us? I made contracts with moving weather. Tried to invent ramen you’d actually love. Learned how to walk at your speed. Kept reaching for your hand while you were already running. And none of it mattered if I wasn’t really there. ⸻ [Verse 3] Now I’m the enemy, I guess. I don’t know when that happened. There wasn’t a scene. No clean rupture. No final chapter. Just panic. Then distance. Then suddenly I was somebody you had to get away from. And then— nothing. You moved on like somebody hit skip. No curiosity. No looking back. No wanting to know what happened to me after you left me in it. And that part hurts in a particularly stupid place. Because I wanted to know everything. Every unfinished story you abandoned halfway through. Every tiny piece you forgot you’d mentioned. My brain kept them open waiting for the endings. You never came back to finish them. ⸻ [Bridge] I don’t think you thought I was fun. I don’t think you really knew me. I don’t think you loved me. And I can say all of that without making what I felt less real. That’s the cruel bit. There doesn’t have to be a matching witness. There doesn’t have to be equal weight on the other side. I can have loved you completely and still have been a passing season to you. I can know that. I can hate it. I can survive it. I just don’t know how to stop loving you because the evidence changed. Love has never been particularly interested in evidence. ⸻ [Final Chorus] So maybe I’ll always love you. God, I hope not. But maybe. Maybe some part of me will always turn its head when somebody says something you would have laughed at. Maybe ferries will always have you in them. Maybe Europe will always feel slightly fictional. Maybe every 0.5 photo will look like proof from a life nobody else remembers. Maybe I’ll keep wondering whether you ever looked for me when I wasn’t there or whether I only noticed because I was always looking for you. I thought love meant staying. You thought— I don’t know what you thought. That’s the problem. You never finished the story. ⸻ [Outro] And my brain has trouble closing loops. So you left in the middle of a sentence and I have been living inside the comma. Waiting for a period that isn’t coming. Trying to understand how somebody can be the most real thing that ever happened to you and still leave you wondering— did Europe happen? Did any of it happen? Was I there? Was I ever there? I know I was. I know I was. I know I was. I just don’t know if you saw me.