[Verse 1] You showed up with a suitcase and a Sunday kind of smile I was learning how to leave town, you were staying for a while Your coffee on my tailgate, your boots beside my door Every little almost felt like something worth fighting for [Pre-Chorus] But the calendar kept turning, and the miles kept telling truth I had one foot in tomorrow, you were asking me to choose [Chorus] We were right hearts, wrong season Good thing, bad timing, no good reason I found forever in the middle of goodbye You were my true love at the wrong time in my life Now your name sits quiet where my best days used to be Right hearts, wrong season, still breaking me [Verse 2] I hear your laugh in an old truck when the gravel starts to roll See the porch light in September, feel your hand inside my coat You wanted something steady, I was chasing something new Turns out every road I took kept circling back to you [Pre-Chorus] Now the years have made me honest, but they cannot make you stay I would trade a thousand tomorrows for one unhurried yesterday [Chorus] We were right hearts, wrong season Good thing, bad timing, no good reason I found forever in the middle of goodbye You were my true love at the wrong time in my life Now your name sits quiet where my best days used to be Right hearts, wrong season, still breaking me [Bridge] If I could meet you where I am tonight I’d pull you close and get the moment right But love can be true and still lose its chance Some doors close softly, never open back [Final Chorus] We were right hearts, wrong season Good thing, bad timing, no good reason I found forever in the middle of goodbye You were my true love at the wrong time in my life Now your name sits quiet where my best days used to be Right hearts, wrong season, still breaking me Still breaking me Yeah, you’re still breaking me [Outro] Right hearts, wrong season Wrong time in my life
