[Verse 1] I raise my eyes to Finbar give him that doubtful stare He takes the seat across from me arms on the table there “You don’t believe it?” he says like I’m the one unsure But I’ve heard the same old answer since I was little for sure No one knows where we came from that’s what they taught me right Keep your head down, keep it moving let the dark stay dark tonight And I was fine with that answer plain, clean, easy to hold Better than some wild old story wrapped in glitter and gold [Pre-Chorus] Now he leans in like a spark like he’s got a second key Talking like the truth was waiting somewhere out beyond the sea I fold my arms, I don’t flinch I can hear my own heart say If you want me, come with proof don’t bring me just a maybe [Chorus] I don’t believe it I don’t believe it That fantasy won’t land on me I don’t believe it I don’t believe it Show me the shape, show me the sea [Verse 2] Finbar keeps his voice so calm like he’s used to doubt Says the world has got a doorway that they never talked about Says the oldest hands were hiding what the younger ones forgot But my mind keeps pinning back to what I know and what I got If nobody knows the answer then nobody gets to sell A pretty little legend just to cast a better spell I watched his hands on the tabletop watched the truth inside his face Still I couldn’t make my feet step into that empty space [Pre-Chorus] Now he leans in like a spark like he’s got a second key Talking like the truth was waiting somewhere out beyond the sea I fold my arms, I don’t flinch I can hear my own heart say If you want me, come with proof don’t bring me just a maybe [Chorus] I don’t believe it I don’t believe it That fantasy won’t land on me I don’t believe it I don’t believe it Show me the shape, show me the sea [Bridge] Maybe I’m scared of the answer maybe I like my unknown Better a blank page in my hands than a throne built out of bones Still, there’s something in his silence that keeps pulling at my name Like the truth could change my whole world and leave me standing in the flame [Chorus] I don’t believe it I don’t believe it That fantasy won’t land on me I don’t believe it I don’t believe it Show me the shape, show me the sea
