[Verse 1] I see the way you look at me when he's not around You say we're just friends, but girl, I know better now You like to keep me close enough to stay in the game But not enough to say my name [Pre-Chorus] So tell me, tell me, why you call so late? Said it’s nothing, but your voice don’t match your face If you really didn’t care at all Then why you always take my calls? [Chorus] Hypothetically, if I told you I wanted more Would you run to me or keep me waiting at the door? You play it safe, but you know it ain't fair To keep me here, to keep me here Hypothetically, what if I just walked away? Would you stop me, beg me, tell me you want me to stay? You say "What if" like you don't even care But girl, you're scared, yeah, you're scared [Verse 2] You drop my name in every casual conversation Like you’re tryna see if he picks up on the hesitation Oh, you’re looking for a reason, but you won’t decide Why you scared to cross that line? [Pre-Chorus] So tell me, tell me, why you call so late? Said it’s nothing, but your voice don’t match your face If you really didn’t care at all Then why you always take my calls? [Chorus] Hypothetically, if I told you I wanted more Would you run to me or keep me waiting at the door? You play it safe, but you know it ain't fair To keep me here, to keep me here Hypothetically, what if I just walked away? Would you stop me, beg me, tell me you want me to stay? You say "What if" like you don't even care But girl, you're scared, yeah, you're scared [Bridge] What if, what if you let yourself fall? What if, what if I'm what you wanted all along? Would you finally say it out loud? Or keep me in the dark somehow? [Outro] Hypothetically, if I told you I wanted more Would you run to me or keep me waiting at the door? You say "What if" like you don’t even care But girl, you're scared, yeah, you're scared
