Song Cover Image

Incoherent BORTHDAY Cake

[Spoken Intro] Last year there was no cake. (You mentioned it once.) I mentioned it enough. (Right.) [Intro] THIS YEAR THERE IS CAKE! TOO MUCH FEELING! NOT ENOUGH SHAPE! [Verse 1] One passing “Where was my cake?” Became a legally binding brief You took a minor grievance To the High Court of Buttercream You speak fluent fondant Clean corners, satin seams Then frosting seized the kitchen And rejected geometry [Pre-Chorus] Is that the front? (There isn’t a front.) Is that bit meant to move? (Don’t touch it.) It leans left It leans right It changes shape When it sees the light [Chorus] INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE Structurally brave Aesthetically vague NO PLAN! ALL HEART! Somehow a work of art INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE Not what I pictured Still made my day It missed the brief In the loveliest way INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE [Post-Chorus] Too much feeling! (Not enough shape!) Too much frosting! (Back away from the cake!) [Verse 2] The piping changed direction The border wouldn’t set One side looked like a wedding One side, a weather event The candles stood at angles Like witnesses in court The frosting made a statement But declined to give a source [Break] Taste? (Lovely.) Shape? (Under investigation.) Theme? (Affection.) Presentation? (ESCALATION!) [Chorus] INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE Structurally brave Aesthetically vague NO PLAN! ALL HEART! Somehow a work of art INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE Not what I pictured Still made my day It missed the brief In the loveliest way INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE [Breakdown] FONDANT! MASTERED! FROSTING! UNSUPERVISED! SPONGE! PRESENT! GEOMETRY! COMPROMISED! NO FRONT! NO BACK! NO COHERENT PLAN OF ATTACK! [Bridge] I asked because last year There wasn’t one You heard the stupid little thing And made me one It wasn’t neat It wasn’t quite the plan But I knew exactly what it meant When you put it in my hands [Spoken Break] I really do love it. (Then stop staring at it.) [Final Chorus] INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE Structurally brave Aesthetically vague NO PLAN! ALL HEART! Somehow a work of art INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE Not what I pictured Still made my day It missed the brief In the loveliest way INCOHERENT BIRTHDAY CAKE [Outro] Next year... (We’re buying one.)