
[Verse 1] Was it just a moment when I stayed with you that night? Did the morning change the meaning of the words beneath the light? Did you need a little shelter till another storm was through? Were you trying to forget him while I learned the shape of you? You said you had been busy; I believed you every time Then a minute turned to days, and the days became a sign I don't know if there was somebody; I won't say I know I just know you stopped explaining where the two of us could go [Pre-Chorus] I can take a truth that hurts I can hear a hard goodbye You can find a hundred words Could you leave me one that's right? [Chorus] Tell me why, tell me why Was it love, was it lust, were we buying time? Tell me why, tell me why Did you mean it when you looked me in my eyes? I don't need you back to get a little peace I just need the truth you never gave to me Tell me why, tell me why Did the feeling leave before you said goodbye? [Verse 2] Was it so easy giving up, or did you struggle, too? Did you practice what to tell me, then decide you couldn't do it? You could have said you weren't ready, could have said I wasn't right I would've hurt a little sooner; I'd be further on tonight I kept giving you the language you could use to let me down You kept leaving every sentence with no ending and no sound Now I'm writing in the margins of the days I can't rewind Trying not to make a verdict out of what you left behind [Chorus] Tell me why, tell me why Was it love, was it lust, were we buying time? Tell me why, tell me why Did you mean it when you looked me in my eyes? I don't need you back to get a little peace I just need the truth you never gave to me Tell me why, tell me why Did the feeling leave before you said goodbye? [Bridge] If the answer never reaches me The morning still arrives I can leave the question open And get on with my life But for tonight, just for tonight Let this last little question ride [Final Chorus] Tell me why, tell me why Was it love, was it lust, were we buying time? Tell me why, tell me why Did you mean it when you looked me in my eyes? I don't need you back to get a little peace And I won't make your answer all that's left of me Tell me why, tell me why One last question, then I turn out the light

