[Verse 1] You like waking up at sunrise I don’t even sleep ‘til two You’re all lists and clean white t-shirts I’m red wine on velvet shoes You read poems in the margins I draw devils on the page You walk careful, counting footsteps I kick doors and light the stage (yeah) [Chorus] Why? You’re sugar in my black coffee Why? You’re Sunday in my bad week We clash, we crash, we spark, we fly We fit so wrong it feels just right And I don’t know why I don’t know why (why, why) [Verse 2] You say “breathe before you answer” I say “say it with your chest” You save every faded ticket I forget where I left my dress You want quiet, curtains half-closed I want colors in the sky You make plans and I make trouble We make sense and I can’t lie (no) [Chorus] Why? You’re sugar in my black coffee Why? You’re Sunday in my bad week We clash, we crash, we spark, we fly We fit so wrong it feels just right And I don’t know why I don’t know why (why, why) [Bridge] Maybe it’s the way you look at me Like I’m chaos worth the cost Maybe it’s the way I pull you close When you’re certain we are lost Two strange stars in the same dark sky Too far gone to say goodbye Still your heartbeat finds my broken rhyme Every time, every time (hey) [Verse 3] You fold corners, mark the pages (mm) I tear chapters, skip the truth (rip it) You keep calm in conversations I throw sparks inside the booth (ha) You wear patience like a halo I wear thunder on my sleeve (yeah) You say “stay,” I say “don’t cage me” Still you’re all I ever need (wait) You sip slow, taste every moment I burn fast, I chase the high You build homes out of forever I build wings and learn to fly But every road I try escaping Leads me right back to your eyes [Pre-Chorus] You cool me down when I’m electric I light you up when you’re too still We’re contradiction, kinetic But somehow bending to each will [Chorus] Why? You’re sugar in my black coffee (sweet) Why? You’re Sunday in my bad week (yeah) We clash, we crash, we spark, we fly We fit so wrong it feels just right And I don’t know why I don’t know why (why, why) [Breakdown] Tell me how your quiet found me In the middle of my noise How your whisper cuts through everything Like the softest, strongest voice I was never good at staying Never good at playing nice But you make me want forever Even if I don’t know why [Final Chorus] Why? You’re sugar in my black coffee Why? You’re Sunday in my bad week We clash, we crash, we spark, we fly We fit so wrong it feels just right And I don’t know why I don’t know why (why, why) [Outro] Maybe love ain’t meant for reason Maybe hearts don’t need a plan You say “stay,” and I’m still running But I’m running back to you Every “why” turns into something That feels dangerously true So I’ll stop asking the question I don’t need to know the why [Instrumental Outro] A faster, denser instrumental run resolves into a firm final hit and short fading tail.