Song Cover Image

Lie to me Correctly

[Intro] Don't insult me with the truth this late at night. [Pause] You know better. [Motif] [Verse 1] You came in wearing innocence like something tailored for the room, with somebody else's alibi still lingering in your perfume. Said, "Traffic." I said, "Of course." We both admired the performance. You kissed me like a witness you were trying to make accomplice. I could've asked where you had been. You could've asked who called me twice. Instead you poured another drink and let me compliment your lies. [Pre-Chorus] Don't give me facts. Give me finesse. If we're gonna make a mess, at least make it impressive. [Chorus] Lie to me correctly. Look me dead between the eyes. Don't waste a beautiful deception on an amateur disguise. Make it elegant. Make it reckless. Make me almost want it true. If you're gonna lie directly to me... [Pause] Let me lie correctly too. [Motif] [Verse 2] I told you, "She's nobody." You smiled— "Then I suppose that lipstick underneath your collar must've blossomed like a rose." Touché. You said, "He's just a friend." I laughed into my glass. We're getting so damn good at this we hardly need to ask. You know exactly where I'm weakest. I know precisely where you bend. We weaponize the details, then make tenderness pretend. And every time one catches one, there's that little flash of pride— Not because the lie was convincing. Because we noticed how they tried. [Build] [Chorus] Lie to me correctly. Look me dead between the eyes. Don't waste a beautiful deception on an amateur disguise. Make it elegant. Make it reckless. Make me almost want it true. If you're gonna lie directly to me... Let me lie correctly too. [Riff] [Bridge] Maybe honesty would ruin us. [Pause] Imagine that. No hidden phones. No careful wording. No lipstick. No suspicious gaps. Nothing left to investigate. Nothing clever left to catch. Just you. Just me. [Breath] God... how unbearably dull is that? [Drop] [Final Chorus] So lie to me correctly. Put some poetry in the crime. Tell me I'm the only one with somebody else's taste still on your wine. I'll call you irreplaceable. You'll swear you've never felt this way. We'll recognize the contradictions... and choose exactly what to say. Lie to me correctly. Don't you DARE become sincere. Because the sweetest lie you've told me... [Pause] is that we only keep coming back because neither one of us cares. [Outro] You staying? [Pause] "Absolutely not." [Pause] ...move over.