[Verse 1] We were like peanut butter and pickles, a match so strange, Some called it crazy, but we never thought to change. Now the jar’s half-empty, and the bread’s gone stale, Just another love story that’s destined to fail. [Chorus] Oh, it’s peanut butter and pickle blues, Pointless fights and worn-out shoes. Your exes linger like a bad perfume, And I’m stuck here starin’ at this empty room. Peanut butter and pickle dreams, Nothin’s ever quite as it seems. Our love was messy, our love was true, Now I’m just a fool with these peanut butter and pickle blues. [Verse 2] We’d fight over everything’, like who cares about that bitches hair, Then we’d make up eventually, but the trust just wasnt there. Your exes kept callin’, like they owned a share, And I was just the fool who thought you still cared. [Chorus] Oh, it’s peanut butter and pickle blues, Pointless fights and worn-out shoes. Your exes linger like a bad perfume, And I’m stuck here starin’ at this empty room. Peanut butter and pickle dreams, Nothin’s ever quite as it seems. Our love was messy, our love was true, Now I’m just a fool with these peanut butter and pickle blues. [Bridge] I tried to fix it with a midnight snack, Peanut butter, pickles, but there’s no goin’ back. The bread’s all crumbled, the jar’s run dry, Just like our love, it’s sayin’ goodbye. [Chorus] Oh, it’s peanut butter and pickle blues, Pointless fights and worn-out shoes. Your exes linger like a bad perfume, And I’m stuck here starin’ at this empty room. Peanut butter and pickle dreams, Nothin’s ever quite as it seems. Our love was messy, our love was true, Now I’m just a fool with these peanut butter and pickle blues. [Outro] So here’s to the sandwiches we’ll never share, And the love that’s gone like thin, thin air. Your cold heart, I’m done with the fight, I’ll keep my pickles, and sleep alone tonight.
