[Verse 1] Sweet wind blowing through the midnight street Chelsea, your perfume still lingers on Something like yogurt — a love gone slightly sour [Chorus] Days like butterscotch, melting slow Your selfish sweetness still on my lips Chelsea, every time I think of you My chest folds in I can’t go back now [Verse 2] Moonlight caught in the back alley shadows Your silhouette — a mirage too far to touch Chelsea, only your name refuses to dissolve [Verse 3] Tried so hard to play it grown, play it black Ordered my coffee bitter, no cream, no sugar But truth is, I couldn’t drink it straight — still just a kid underneath [Bridge] Didn’t know back then How heavy a lonely night could be In my pocket, an excuse Still half-melted, still unsaid [Chorus] Days like butterscotch, still so sweet Your kindness stays, soft in my chest Chelsea, every time I think of you One tear falls down I can’t go back now [Outro] Chelsea, your memory won’t fade away Yogurt’s sour taste still on my tongue Never noticed how gentle that coffee was Guess that’s just growing up bye bye Chelsea
