Song Cover Image

16. The End

[Open instantly with Lyrics] I don’t really know why I’m saying this now. [soft, uncertain] Maybe it’s just to stop it circling in my head when everything gets quiet. As I sit here, alone, in the soft glow of lantern light. The rain lightly dancing in the midnight window. Lightning flashes in the distance. Here it comes again. The doubt starts flooding in. It’s been a few years since that night. Not long enough that people talk like it belongs to history. But long enough that they’ve started seeing me for the man I truly am again. But I’m not sure that’s something anyone ever gets right. --- I tell myself I’ve moved on. But it comes back anyway. The gunfire. The smoke. The sent of gunpowder and coal in the air. And something more. Something I can’t settle no matter how many times I try. --- Because I keep coming back to one question. Not what I did… but what might’ve happened when I did it. That night started like most did back then. Dust in the air. Tension in the town. Word had already spread before I arrived. I told myself it was simple. You show up. You do what needs doing. Respond without hesitation. You don’t let doubt take root. But that’s the part I can’t stop thinking about. Because I don’t know which moment changed everything… or if it was already too late before I even drew my weapon. --- I used to be sure. Not about everything. But enough. Enough to sleep. Enough to look people in the eye with conviction. Now even that feels borrowed from someone else. I keep trying to distinguish memory and truth from what I’ve told myself. But they sound the same now. His face doesn’t stay still anymore. None of them do. Neither does the moment. It keeps shifting depending on what I’m unsure of. And I don’t know what that means for the truth, and the outcome. Only that I don’t trust it the way I used to. And then there’s the part I never talk about. The child. I tried to do right by him. Tried to hold it together the way a man is supposed to. Honor, loyalty, strength. To keep my truth. To stand firm. To not let it spill onto everyone else. But I’ve started wondering if I failed anyway. Maybe that’s why he still looks at me the way he does. And probably always will. Because if I was wrong… everything after bends out of shape. And if I was right… then why does it still feel like I wasn’t? --- I don’t expect this to fix anything. I just needed it to exist somewhere outside of me. Because carrying it inside gets too heavy in the silence. Jake… I don’t trust that night anymore. Not the way I used to. I fired. He fired. My deputy fired. Chaos erupted. Innocence falls to the dirt and onto the rails, bleeding and fading. Yet, somehow, on that night, WE, all walked away. Not with certainty. Not with clarity. Just movement that became consequence before I could name it. And I’ve started to wonder if certainty was something I invented afterward just to survive it. --- I don’t know what a man is supposed to do with that. There isn’t a version where I walk away clean. Only versions where I convince myself I did. There is a bold line between memory and reality. When that line fades… Sanity tends to fade with it. Ultimately… I may be just as guilty as he was. And in the end, his consequence sealed his fate along with mine. Difference is, I have to live with it, and he was set free from the cage I put him in, and from the agony of uncertainty. --- So I’ll leave this here between these sacred pages. Not because it fixes anything. Or changes anything, but because my hands may not be as clean as I once assured myself they were. --- [Whisperd Gently] SAM REED. [Pause] [Child Narrator] ā€œIt wasn’t meant to be found. Folded too many times. Pressed into pages no one opened anymore. It slipped out without warning. And floated to the hardwood floor. At first just ink and dust. A letter from Sam Reed. --- It wasn’t read all at once. Just fragments passed in silence. And slowly it stopped being a letter. And became something heavier. Something inherited. --- By the time it was understood, it belonged to distance. To years that softened names but not consequence. --- And there was something no one needed to say. He wasn’t asking to be forgiven. Only to be understood. Or witnessed, or set free. --- And so we kept it. Not because it answered anything. But because it didn’t.ā€ --- And That… Is Life… at high noon.