(Verse 1) A silver spoon, a simple jar A sweet affair, beneath the stars He was a swirl of nutty charm A little salty, keeping warm He watched her melt, a chocolate dream A river flowing, dark and lean Jelly was the one he swore to love But she's so fruity, a dove from above He saw the fudge, he saw the chips He saw the ganache on her lips They tried to hide it, what they had But the taste was just too good to be bad (Chorus) Oh, the spoon and the butter And the chocolate so rich Jelly's sitting there with her jammy pitch A sticky secret, a forbidden blend A story with a bittersweet end Peanut butter and chocolate, a sinful taste A perfect pair in this hurried haste (Verse 2) Jelly's been waiting, red and pure A loyal fruit, she was so sure That he was hers, her only one But he was out having a little fun He'd sneak away, late at night A little spoon to share the light She'd try to call, she'd try to text She'd wonder why he was so perplexed He'd tell her "I'm just a little stuck" While he was swimming in chocolate luck The fridge was a witness to their lies Underneath the cold, electric skies (Chorus) Oh, the spoon and the butter And the chocolate so rich Jelly's sitting there with her jammy pitch A sticky secret, a forbidden blend A story with a bittersweet end Peanut butter and chocolate, a sinful taste A perfect pair in this hurried haste (Verse 3) Jelly found out, she saw the mess The broken jar of her own happiness She cried a river of crimson tears A broken heart, a thousand fears He tried to tell her it was a mistake A moment of weakness for goodness sake But the taste of them, it couldn't be denied Two ingredients that were meant to collide Jelly packed up her things and left A lonely toast, now completely bereft She found a new life, a new jam to be While they were left in their sweet misery (Chorus) Oh, the spoon and the butter And the chocolate so rich Jelly's sitting there with her jammy pitch A sticky secret, a forbidden blend A story with a bittersweet end Peanut butter and chocolate, a sinful taste A perfect pair in this hurried haste
