[Verse 1] Two names upon the roster Two flags above the door They knew exactly who was who And never asked for more A year became another The welcome stayed in place Until the same familiar names Began to look misplaced [Chorus] Who let them in? Who gave them the keys? They ask it like a secret Like it's some mystery Who let them in? Who let them stay? It took a little fear To rewrite yesterday [Verse 2] A warning in the darkness Four minutes on the clock A familiar name appeared online And suddenly they saw a plot No one could trace a message No proof of what was said But the story sounded cleaner Once the verdict filled their heads [Chorus] Who let them in? Who gave them the keys? They ask it like a secret Like it's some mystery Who let them in? Who let them stay? It took a little fear To rewrite yesterday [Bridge] "They hardly ever flew with us" Was suddenly the line As if that little detail Hadn't been there all the time They called it common sense before Then called it a mistake A problem they'd been living with Became too much to take [Final Chorus] Who let them in? Who gave them the keys? They ask it like a secret Like it's some mystery Who let them in? Who let them stay? They signed the invitation Then rewrote yesterday
