In the kitchen, you were talking loud I heard my name and turned around Your sister laughed, you filled her glass Then somebody asked what makes it last You said, “He’s just easy to love” I had to laugh and look away For a second, I thought Who could that be? Then you looked right at me And everybody nodded Like they knew something I didn’t You kept talking I kept listening Would you still stay? Would you still? Would you? Would you still stay? Then your brother brought up That night I locked my keys inside You laughed before I could Like you’d heard it fifty times Someone said “I don’t know how you live with him” You smiled Like you already had an answer And said “Yeah That’s one of my favorites” I watched you talking Like it was nothing Like you didn’t know What that did to me Would you still stay? Would you still? Would you? Would you still stay? You went back To whatever you were saying Everybody else did too But I stayed there For a while Would you still stay? Would you still? Would you? Would you still stay? Would you still stay? You caught me staring That smile again The one that says You already know Something I don’t Would you still stay? Would you still? Would you? Would you still stay? Would you still stay? Would you still stay? Would you still? Would you? Would you still stay? Would you?