Song Cover Image

An Open Letter to One, Mr. S. Shady

Hello Is this thing on? Thanks for coming out tonight. This one goes out to a special man in my heart. Hi, my name is (my name is) Dark Poet. I’m a whitey from Michigan, Recovering edgelord, surrounded by Christians. Renewal is chic, that sweet ol’ redemption. Teachers fuck students, but it’s all my sin Let’s go back to the Midwest again. Where the boys are boys And the girls are girls Bonfire flings and dresses twirled It’s plaid shirts and American pride. Hay bail flirts and dirt bike rides Where the water’s led and the cows are bred It’s simpler times, simpler places, All around me, familiar faces. Just nevermind the statutory— Rapists Tonight, we’re cleanin’ out our closets. What? Thought a them-they couldn’t hold on to hate? That D-E-I meant nothin’ to hide? Come on, Shady, let’s spell out our white boy rage— I’ll match you, page for page. Hee hee, look at me, white boy shock rhymes are easy, The truth will set you free Let me see, here it goes, Get in loser, We’re cashin’ in on sorrow Hi, Did you know that? Mrs. Bazel loves a quarterback. Hi, Did you know that? Pastor Paul likes ‘em fourteen Hi, Did you know that? Priest John’ll teach ‘em good Hi, Did you know that? Cardinal Dave’ll give ‘em wood. Damn, I know we’re not best pals But, are these really the guys and the gals You want teachin’ and leadin’ Your daughters and granddaughters. Like lambs to the slaughter. Hey Mr. He/Him, I got some news Your slurs, they’re nothing new Neither is the playbook happening right now. You coulda punched anywhere, you went down. Wow! You’re so manly now! Hi, my name is (my name is) Slim Poet Wait, no. My name is (my name is) Dark Slim Who even am I? (My name is) Dark Shady? (My name is) Oh wait, I remember now The one in class who spoke too loud, The big bad white boy, not from 8 mile Look at me: a real-life woke, come on and stare, Ok, if you wanna fight fair, Three times in the mirror, Call me by your name Like gay Beetlejuice, I’ll be right there (White Americaaaaaa!) Now now I know you don't like pronouns That's fine, I'm all grown now But how do you feel about verbs? Maybe you’re right, it's absurd, I’ve got it! They’re all just buzzwords No need to get butthurt I'll take he/him, it, they, she/her That just leaves Shady/you with was/were. I respect you, though, Your rhymes are indelible Your love’s incredible, your hate so sellable. Just a little weird you made it Oedipal. Maybe unfellable, but at least they’re edible, digestible Cuz I’m a mental cannibal, emotionally sadomasochistic Hannibal No worries, though, I’m not here to put down the feral animal Just so you see, do-si-do, no one knows, where we go When the wolf’s in shepherds’ clothes. But someone’s gotta pay the bills and make cheap thrills Uncle Sam needs shills and scapegoats for America to hate on while our resources are drained on and on and on the story goes, treason upon treason And for some reason, They say I’m the one who blows. Hey Shady, am I doing it right? That’s small town Michigan alright. I know I know. You’re branded resentment Don’t blame me, though. I’m just a phantom. The ghost of America Past & Present You’re so evil. You’re so evil. Yeah yeah, so was gram gram. I got mad and pulled a knievel Crash and burn. They loved the way I lied Least til’ they saw what’s inside. Had three daughters, so you’re a feminist. You know the story, the birds and the bees Apples and trees. You said your mom’s a bitch? I was raised by narcissists. We’re so evil. We’re so evil. We hide behind our alter egos Go ahead, let’s go for broke. Become the spokesman that you wrote, White rage incarnate—just one note. Mine was part of the White America That was sold. Business is business, I know how it goes But you’ve got to know, It’s pretty gross Gonna get cancelled? Better blame the gays. Fags, drags, thems, theys You just gotta punch. I know that, don’t be dumb. I don’t give a fuck whether you punch it’s where you aim. So don’t hold back, stop hesitating That’s why we’re all still waiting for the Real Slim Shady™. To please stand up.