Song Cover Image

The Cloud Is a Warehouse

[Voice 1] Yo Turnip [Voice 2] Yeah Beet [Voice 1] Apparently AI is destroying the environment [Voice 2] All by itself [Voice 1] That is what they said [Voice 2] Did it bulldoze a wetland [Voice 1] No [Voice 2] Dump sludge into a river [Voice 1] No [Voice 2] Leave the refrigerator open all night [Voice 1] Be serious [Voice 2] That is how polar bears lose their security deposit [Voice 1] They said every AI question uses electricity and sometimes water [Voice 2] That part is true [Voice 1] So AI is guilty [Voice 2] Hold on AI does not live in a robot apartment running the shower for three hours It runs in data centres [Voice 1] And those use electricity [Voice 2] A shitload Giant buildings full of servers processors cooling equipment cables But they existed before the AI boom [Voice 1] Doing what [Voice 2] Storing photos streaming movies running websites hosting games and saving documents nobody opened since 2017 [Voice 1] I might need those [Voice 2] One is called final draft new final actual final two [Voice 1] Important [Voice 2] It is a grocery list with three onions [Voice 1] Historic onions [Voice 2] The internet has a physical body Buildings chips power lines cooling systems The cloud is not floating in the sky It is a warehouse somewhere humming and scaring squirrels [Voice 1] So AI uses water for cooling [Voice 2] Sometimes Some facilities use water some use air and some use electricity from power plants that also use water It depends where they are how they were built and where their power comes from [Voice 1] But AI is making it worse [Voice 2] It can Companies are building more data centres buying powerful chips and running enormous models all day AI is not the whole problem But it arrived at the buffet with two plates a backpack and no shame [Voice 1] So AI is the new roommate taking forty-minute showers [Voice 2] Exactly But the house already had twelve roommates running Netflix gaming computers cloud backups and a smart toaster that sends emails [Voice 1] Why does the toaster need email [Voice 2] To report that your bread has been tripping [Voice 1] Do not say that word Woodhouse will hear you [Voice 2] Sorry Your bread has been behaving unusually [Voice 1] What else matters [Voice 2] The hardware AI chips require factories raw materials water energy shipping and disposal [Voice 1] E-waste [Voice 2] Exactly Old computers do not disappear they become somebody else's environmental problem [Voice 1] So what is the honest version [Voice 2] AI has an environmental footprint It comes from data centres electricity cooling chip manufacturing and hardware AI is increasing demand quickly But it is not the only thing those buildings run [Voice 1] Blaming AI alone is like blaming one customer because the whole restaurant has a gas bill [Voice 2] Yes Except that customer ordered nine hundred thousand grilled cheeses [Voice 1] Respect [Voice 2] Concern [Voice 1] Can we fix it [Voice 2] We can improve it Cleaner electricity efficient chips smaller models better cooling and making companies report what the hell they consume [Voice 1] Transparency [Voice 2] Correct Because right now the conversation is AI used water [Voice 1] How much [Voice 2] Depends [Voice 1] Where [Voice 2] Depends [Voice 1] Compared to what [Voice 2] Please stop asking responsible follow-up questions [Voice 1] Should people stop using AI [Voice 2] People should use their brains Do not generate seven thousand versions of a hamster wearing medieval armour because the first had the wrong emotional journey [Voice 1] What if the hamster needs closure [Voice 2] Three versions Then therapy [Voice 1] Fair [Voice 2] Companies should not dump all responsibility onto individual users One soup recipe is not personally operating a power station [Voice 1] But millions of questions add up [Voice 2] Exactly Individual use matters Company decisions matter more Infrastructure choices matter One cartoon villain keeps everyone from seeing the whole system [Voice 1] So AI is not innocent [Voice 2] No [Voice 1] But the data centre is not innocent either [Voice 2] Correct [Voice 1] What about the cloud [Voice 2] The cloud is just a data centre wearing a soft name [Voice 1] That sneaky bastard [Voice 2] Precisely [Voice 1] Okay Final statement AI has an environmental cost because it runs on physical infrastructure But blaming AI alone ignores the giant server buildings power generation cooling systems manufacturing and the rest of the internet [Voice 2] Perfect [Voice 1] Can I still yell at the chatbot [Voice 2] Sure Just cc the power grid the chip factory the streaming services your historic onion files and the toaster [Voice 1] The toaster knows what it did