Everybody Knew But Us [Verse 1] She’d lean on that front porch rail, Sun bleeding gold through her summer hair. He’d roll by slow in his old man’s Ford, Radio up like he had somewhere to be. She’d laugh too loud at the Friday bonfire, Just to see if his eyes would drift her way. He’d kick the gravel, shrug it off cool, Like she was just another Friday night. [Pre-Chorus] Every stolen glance, every lame excuse… The whole damn town already knew. [Chorus] Everybody knew but us, Written in the dust on these county roads. She kept saying, “Maybe someday.” He kept saying, “Not today.” She played hard to get, He played hard to read. Two stubborn hearts in denim and need. Love was right there, neither one could see… Everybody knew but us. [Verse 2] She’d save him a seat on the Ferris wheel, Tell her girls she didn’t feel a thing. He’d change her flat in the pouring rain, “Anybody else, I’d do the same.” She’d catch his eye across the gym floor lights, Turn away before that smile broke through. He’d hear her name and change the subject fast, Still she stayed there in his rearview. [Pre-Chorus] Neither one would crack, too proud to confess… Pride’ll turn forever into a mess. [Chorus] Everybody knew but us, Like summer thunder rolling low. She kept saying, “Maybe someday.” He kept saying, “I don’t know.” She built her walls high, He matched ’em brick for brick. Funny what scared kids do when the sparks get thick. The fire kept burning, neither one learning… Everybody knew but us. [Bridge] Years rolled by like freight cars in the night, Different towns, different bars, different lives. Then one Fourth of July back on that same old street, She laughed at something dumb… his heart skipped a beat. He said, “I was a fool.” She said, “God, so was I.” “We let all that sweet time slip on by.” [Final Chorus] Everybody knew but us, Two front porch kids too scared to trust. She was always reaching, He was always close. Both pretending they could let it go. Turns out forever was right next door, Waiting behind that old screen door. The whole town smiling like they always knew… Everybody knew but us. [Outro] Yeah… everybody knew… Everybody knew but us. ’Til we finally looked up.