Song Cover Image

11. The Witness (Name Redacted)

[Verse 1] I was twenty-two that summer, Headed west to start anew. Had a suitcase and a ticket, Same as most the people do. Then the train came to a stop, And the screaming soon began. Men on horseback all around us, Guns and smoke and shaking hands. Crazy what survives in memory. Not the things you’d think you’d keep. I remember a baby’s crying. I remember a woman weep. I remember fear. ⸻ [Chorus] I told them what I saw. At least I tried. But memory ain’t a straight line, No matter how hard you fight. Everybody wanted certainty. Everybody wanted proof. All I ever had Was pieces, of the truth. ⸻ [Verse 2] I saw Billy Jesse on that train. I saw a six shooter, in his hand. That much I’ll swear is true. Saw him shouting. Saw him moving. Saw him fighting through the crowd . Then some shots were fired. Then some innocent people fell. Then all at once my simple train ride. Became my livin’ hell. People always ask me: “Did Billy pull the trigger?” And after all these years… I still don’t remember. ⸻ [Verse 3] The deputies asked me first. Then the railroad lawyers came. Then the men with notebooks Wanted names. “Are you sure?” That’s what they kept asking. “Are you sure?” Again and again. Funny thing is, After enough repetitions, You start wondering If maybe you are. ⸻ [Bridge] Sheriff Reed never threatened me. At least, Not exactly. But he looked me straight in the eyes and said: “People are counting on you.” And I believed him. I still do. But truth and certainty Aren’t always the same thing. ⸻ [Verse 4] Then came the trial. Then came the prison. Then came the stories. Then came the legend. Then came Jake the Reaper. And every time another person died, I wondered if my words Had helped build the road that led there. Not because I lied. Because I might have been wrong. ⸻ [Final Chorus] I told them what I saw. At least I tried. A frightened country girl remembering The worst night of her life. Billy’s gone. Jake’s gone. Sam is gone too. And so many people suffered. From what I was forced to do. They convinced me I was certain. But that’s never been the truth. And all these years later, People still ask what happened. I saw enough To change the outcome, and lock a man away. Still not sure if what I did was the right thing. Even to this day.