
Verse 1 Found you underneath some papers, Face down in a drawer, Same old smile I used to practice, Same eyes I wore before. I know the date, I know the place, I know who stood outside the frame, But knowing every detail Doesn’t make us feel the same. Your hands are mine, your face is mine, At least that’s what I’m told, But I’m looking at a stranger Who just happens to look old In a younger kind of way— Before the years rewrote the truth. It’s strange to miss a version I don’t remember being you. Pre-Chorus I should feel something looking back, Some little pull beneath my skin. But all I see is evidence Of somebody I’ve never been. Chorus Why do I keep your picture If I don’t know who you are? Same eyes, same name, But God, we feel so far apart. I can trace every line From your face into mine, But I can’t find the place Where your life became my life. So why do I keep your picture? What am I holding on to? You look so much like me— But I don’t remember you. Verse 2 Were you happier than I am, Or just better at the pose? Did you already know the ending, Or believe nobody knows? Was that hope behind your teeth, Or just the flash against your eyes? It’s funny what a photograph Can teach itself to lie. I could put you back inside the drawer, Let the darkness keep you young. Let you stay before the damage, Before everything became A collection of revisions, Little deaths nobody sees— How many times can someone change And still call themselves “me”? Pre-Chorus Maybe that’s what growing is: A trail of bodies left behind. Every one of them was certain They’d be me for all of time. Chorus Why do I keep your picture If I don’t know who you are? Same eyes, same name, But God, we feel so far apart. I can trace every line From your face into mine, But I can’t find the place Where your life became my life. So why do I keep your picture? What am I holding on to? You look so much like me— But I don’t remember you. Bridge Maybe I keep you as a witness. Maybe proof that I was there. Maybe throwing you away Feels too much like saying I don’t care. But you don’t need me to remember. I don’t need you to remain. A photograph can hold a moment— It can’t tell me what it means. And maybe that’s the cruelest part: You haven’t changed at all. While I’ve become a thousand men You never got to know. Breakdown SAME FACE. SAME NAME. NOT THE SAME MAN. Tell me what exactly I’m supposed to recognize. SAME BLOOD. SAME BONES. BUT I DON’T KNOW— When did you stop being me And become somebody I survived? Final Chorus Why do I keep your picture If I don’t know who you are? Maybe some things aren’t meant To follow us this far. I can trace every line, But I can’t travel back in time, And I don’t owe my past A place in every future life. So maybe I’ll leave your picture Face down where I found you. You look so much like me— I just don’t need you to.

