[Verse 1] You look me in the eyes and say, “I’m fine” But your quiet tells the truth every time Your hand stays here, but your mind drifts far I keep chasing the man I thought you are I bent my life, made room for you Gave up pieces of the world I knew Now you fit easy in the love I gave While I keep asking if there’s still a place [Pre-Chorus] There’s something under every word you say A shape I feel but can’t explain No proof, no text, no smoking gun Just a heavy ache that won’t let up [Chorus] I can’t prove you’re lying to my face Can’t prove there’s someone taking my place Can’t prove your heart has slipped away But I feel it when you look at me that way You’re comfortable, I’m coming undone You sleep beside me and I feel alone I can’t prove it, I can’t say why But my heart already knows tonight (My heart already knows) [Verse 2] You don’t look at me like you used to do Like there’s a spark when I walk in the room I fix my hair, I wait, I try But your eyes just pass me by Maybe I’m reading into every sign Maybe I’m scared of what I’ll find So I swallow questions, bite my tongue Afraid of the sound when the truth is done [Pre-Chorus] You say, “Baby, there’s nothing going on” Then why does your love feel half gone? How can you hold me close like that And leave me lonely in your arms? [Chorus] I can’t prove you’re lying to my face Can’t prove there’s someone taking my place Can’t prove your heart has slipped away But I feel it when you look at me that way You’re comfortable, I’m coming undone I gave you more than I had to give I can’t prove it, I can’t say why But my heart already knows tonight (My heart already knows) [Bridge] Maybe you never promised forever Maybe I heard what I wanted to hear Maybe you love the way I love you But not the way I need you here And that’s the cruelest part You don’t have to be a liar To leave a wound that deep To let me burn in the fire [Final Chorus] I can’t prove you’re lying to my face But I can’t keep pretending this is safe Can’t prove your heart belongs elsewhere But I know I’m disappearing there I gave you years, I gave you all I gave you the best I had to lose You built a home inside my heart While I was slowly slipping through I can’t prove it, I can’t say why But my heart already knows tonight (My heart already knows) [Outro] So tell me, if I’m wrong Why does my soul feel so cold? I can’t accuse you I can’t make you hold me whole But deep down in the dark Where the truth comes out to glow I can’t prove it But I already know
