[Verse 1] The Tally man, he stands and waits With that jagged smile on his face Long white hair and soul-less eyes Tonight, might be it for me, I might not wake up this time. He comes when the room goes dark. He waits when I'm alone I hear his footsteps echo in the night [Pre-Chorus] From nightmares untold He knows me by name Is he part of my soul, Just Fragments and broken remains [Chorus] The Tally Man He'll find me here The Tally Man In my nightmare Killing Dreams On repeat No matter what I do I can't break free [Verse 2] I'm tossing and turning in bed I can’t outrun what lives in my head I shut my eyes He leans in close, says, Are we having fun yet? To him it's just a game [Pre-Chorus] From nightmares untold He knows me by name Is he part of my soul, Just Fragments and broken remains [Chorus] The Tally Man He finds me here The Tally Man In my nightmare Killing Dreams On repeat No matter what I do I can't break free [Bridge] I hear his laugh In the darkest of night If I don't wake, will we disappear If I fight, will he put me down there's no safe place for me Just that jagged smile Waiting patiently [Final Chorus] The Tally Man He'll find me here The Tally Man In my nightmare Killing Dreams On repeat This restless soul, Stuck in his game No matter what I do I can't escape