[Verse 1] Met you somewhere between midnight and a screen, A little too perfect, a little too keen. I handed you the worst of me right from the start, All the cracked little corners, the rust on my heart. I said, “Here are the reasons you probably should run,” You laughed like my damage was part of the fun. Said you liked every flaw I was trying to hide— And God, for a minute, I believed you were right. [Pre-Chorus] Then you said a few things that didn’t quite land, Little sleights of the tongue I could almost understand. My head said, Careful, my heart said, Who cares? Funny how red flags look pink through a glare. [Chorus] Were you everything I wanted, Or just everything I wanted to believe? Were you really falling for me, Or just getting good at making me believe? I saw the warning written Between every beautiful line— You were either something special Or too damn good to be mine. Now you’re gone, and that’s the part I can’t get through my mind— If you were too good to be true, Why can’t I leave you behind? [Verse 2] You knew where to touch without touching my skin, Knew exactly which doors I was scared to let you in. Three words here, one promise there, Just enough future to keep me there. There were holes in the stories, cracks in the frame, Moments your answers would suddenly change. I caught every signal, I knew every sign, Then professionally lied to this heart of mine. [Pre-Chorus] Maybe I wanted the lie to be true, Maybe suspicion looks ugly on you. Maybe I knew how the ending would go— Still didn’t stop me from needing to know. [Chorus] Were you everything I wanted, Or just everything I wanted to believe? Were you really falling for me, Or just getting good at making me believe? I saw the warning written Between every beautiful line— You were either something special Or too damn good to be mine. Now you’re gone, and that’s the part I can’t get through my mind— If you were too good to be true, Why can’t I leave you behind? [Bridge] Maybe you meant it. Maybe you didn’t. Maybe I’m guilty For filling the distance. Maybe you loved me As much as you could. Maybe the danger Was why it felt good. I can prosecute every word that you said, Build the whole case inside of my head. Convict you by morning, forgive you by two— And by three in the morning, I’m missing you. [Breakdown] I SAW THE SIGNS. I READ THE ROOM. I KNEW THAT SOMETHING DIDN’T ADD UP WITH YOU. SO WHY THE HELL DO I STILL CHECK MY PHONE? WHY DOES SOMEBODY I NEVER REALLY HAD FEEL LIKE SOMEBODY I LOST? [Final Chorus] Were you everything I wanted, Or just everything I needed you to be? Were you really seeing something Worth the trouble when you looked at me? I saw the warning written, I just read between the lines— Because sometimes something dangerous Can feel a lot like something right. Now you’re gone without an answer, And I’m still wasting all this time— Trying to decide if I dodged a bullet… Or watched the best thing pass me by. If you were too good to be true, Why can’t I leave you behind? :::