Song Cover Image

04. The Mother (Elizabeth Jesse)

[Verse 1] I still remember Billy laughin’ On a warm July afternoon. Jake was runnin’ through the tall grass, Chasin’ shadows by the late day moon. We weren’t rich and we weren’t lucky, But we had enough somehow. Funny how the little things Feel like treasure to me now. The railroad came with promises, The bankers came with plans. Then one bad season took the crops Right out of Billy’s hands. ⸻ [Chorus] I don’t care who’s right anymore. I don’t care who broke the law. I buried pieces of my life that night when they took it all. Lost by the law, and one hell of an unlucky draw. One took my husband. One took my son. And somewhere in the middle, I was left with neither one. ⸻ [Verse 2] They came with lanterns in the darkness, Stars pinned proudly on their chest. Jake stood frozen by the doorway, Billy tried to do his best. He looked at me and said, “Take care of that boy.” (“Take care of that boy.”) Those were the last words I ever heard from his lips. The papers called him murderer. The town picked sides by dawn. I was just a wife Trying to figure out how to carry on. ⸻ [Bridge] Billy… Did you do it? I asked that question for years. Did you pull that trigger? Did you spill that blood? Or did they need somebody to blame? I still don’t know. And maybe that’s the hardest part. But none of that matters if you ask my heart! ⸻ [Verse 3] Then Jake started stayin’ out later, Started carryin’ his hurt around. Every year his father’s shadow Pulled him farther from this wretched town. First came anger. Then came whiskey. Then came stories on the rails. Then came wanted posters Nailed to weather-beaten rails. I’d see his face and Billy’s eyes Staring back at me. Holding’ back the tears he never cried. One lost to prison walls, One lost to memory. ⸻ [Chorus] I don’t care who’s right anymore. I don’t care who broke the law. I buried pieces of my life that night they took it all. Lost by the law, and one heeell of an unlucky draw. One took my husband. One took my son. And somewhere in the middle, I was left with neither one. ⸻ [Final Verse] Sheriff Reed still tips his hat Whenever our paths cross. Neither one of us speaks much About everything it cost. Maybe Billy was guilty. Maybe Billy was not. Maybe none of that changes Everything we’ve lost. I stopped looking for answers A long, long time ago. Some wounds don’t heal. Some questions are left untold. ⸻ [Final Chorus] I don’t care who’s right anymore. I don’t care who won the fight. The graveyard’s full of answers That never came to light. Two bad decisions left this family undone. One took my husband. One took my son. And all these years later, I’m still waiting for them to come home