[Verse 1] It was scratched up on a bathroom wall Faded red beneath the light Right where someone dared you just to call On a reckless Friday night Don't need the whole thing, wrote out I knew the rhythm like a song Eight-six-seven burned in my head Been dialing it all night long [Pre-Chorus] Quarter drops, dial tone Waiting for her voice to come on [Chorus] 867โ€ฆ thatโ€™s as far as I get now The rest just disappears somehow Jenny, I used to reach you every time Now Iโ€™m only hearing dead lines 867โ€ฆ echo in the tone Like Iโ€™m dialing all alone Jenny changed her number And erased what I thought I owned [Verse 2] Neon buzzing gives this bar room a glow Same old booth, same cracked glass But the numbers that I used to know Ainโ€™t the ones that answer back No โ€œhello,โ€ no mystery No voice pulling me in again Just a cold machine repeating โ€œThis call canโ€™t reach that line againโ€ [Pre-Chorus] Every digit I held tight Faded out into the night [Chorus] 867โ€ฆ thatโ€™s all I remember now The rest wonโ€™t come back around Jenny, I was so sure I could find you In every late-night dial Iโ€™d run through 867โ€ฆ stuck inside my head Like a page somebody read Jenny changed her number Left the story there for dead [Bridge] โ€œCome a little closerโ€-thatโ€™s what it meant Every mark on that wall was heaven-sent Now itโ€™s painted over, nothing to see Just a ghost of who she used to be [Breakdown (soft)] Eightโ€ฆ sixโ€ฆ sevenโ€ฆ Thatโ€™s all I got left Five... three... oh nine's in heavenโ€ฆ [Final Chorus] 867โ€ฆ fading like a dream now No connection, no way through now Jenny, guess you finally cut the line Left me hanging between the signs 867โ€ฆ calling out your name But it never sounds the same Jenny changed her number And nothingโ€™s left but the game [Outro] Yeah, the wallโ€™s been wiped clean nowโ€ฆ But 867โ€™s still chasing me around