[Verse 1] Plastic fangs on the dash Candy wrappers by your feet Fog rolls over front yards Jack-o’-lanterns watch the street You trace scars on my hand Say “dare me” under your breath Porch lights flicker behind us Every step a little test [Chorus] Halloween will never be the same after tonight We crossed a line in the dark Under broken porch light Masks on the floor Hearts showing their bite Halloween will never be the same After tonight [Verse 2] Your lipstick on my cloak Smudged like some red spell We laugh too loud at nothing Trying not to tell Doorways Spinning cobwebs Your eyes won’t look away Rumors run like children But we’re the ones who stayed [Chorus] Halloween will never be the same after tonight We crossed a line in the dark Under broken porch light Masks on the floor Hearts showing their bite Halloween will never be the same After tonight [Bridge] All these ghosts in cheap white sheets Can’t compete with what we did You said “promise you’ll remember” (remember) I said “how could I ever forget?” [Chorus] Halloween will never be the same after tonight We crossed a line in the dark Under broken porch light Masks on the floor Hearts showing their bite Halloween will never be the same After tonight
