[Verse 1 — His Voice, Sung Low, Minimal Instrumentation] What the fuck... That's all I could get out, just “what the fuck” My wife didn't look up, she just said it quiet: “Yeah... what the fuck, Jeff.” Four of us in this room, him staring at me, my wife won't look at me So I turned to the other woman, said, “TELL ME THAT BABY AIN'T MINES!!” She just dropped her head and started crying then she said yes no I don't know, I said, What the hell that mean! [Chorus — His Voice, Sung, Hard and Simple] One phone, one lie, now the whole room knows Late night creep, and the truth came home One phone, one lie, four lives on the line Late night creep—now we all pay the price [Verse 2 — His Voice, Recounting What She Told Him] my wife started to tell her story told us she'd read my phone while I was in the shower A whole year of lies hit her in under an hour She said she cried on that bathroom floor till she couldn't breathe no more Then then stood up and swore she'd cry no more She told us she'd pushed me away, kept her distance That woman was like family, the friend she trusted Then she decided she'd hurt us both with one move That woman took her husband, so she'd take that woman's too [Chorus — His Voice, Sung, Hard and Simple] One phone, one lie, now the whole room knows Late night creep, and the truth came home One phone, one lie, four lives on the line Late night creep—now we all pay the price [Verse 3 — His Voice, Recounting What She Told Him] she said while y'all was creeping we would spend weekends together She said she had dinner ready when her friend's man walked through the door Asked him about his day, gave him the attention I never gave her before She laid his clothes out, ran his bath water hot Gave him everything she said I forgot She told us she made sure she treated him more like a husband than his wife ever could [Chorus — His Voice, Sung, Hard and Simple] One phone, one lie, now the whole room knows Late night creep, and the truth came home One phone, one lie, four lives on the line Late night creep—now we all pay the price [Bridge — His Voice, Stripped Back, Keys and Vocal Only] She's right — I didn't care, I pushed her away, that's on me I was wrong and she was wrong, ain't nobody right We was family once, look at us now The other woman holding her stomach, we all wanna know whose it is But ain't nobody saying it [Outro — His Voice, Then Wife Speaks] Somebody gotta answer. But ain't nobody sure. [Music thins to keys and a low heartbeat] My wife looked at her, then turned and looked at me. She said, “I'm still not done with yall. I got one more surprise.” [She touches her stomach] [Wife — Spoken, Calm] I'm pregnant too. [Music cuts]
