[Intro with a sad guitar riff] I thought you had already left him That your marriage was already done You said there wasn't any love left And we had a chance to carry on I never thought to question Never thought you'd lead me wrong I was falling hard and fast for you Believing you all along [Chorus] I thought we were in love God, I wanted to believe You made me think your heart was mine While you were lying through your teeth I gave you everything I had You made a fool out of me I thought we were in love You were never who you claimed to be [Verse] Then your husband showed up at my door Said you were still together I couldn't believe what he was saying I thought we could be forever When he left, I turned to you Asked you to tell me why You couldn't give me a straight answer So I told you goodbye [Chorus] I thought we were in love God, I wanted to believe You made me think your heart was mine While you were lying through your teeth I gave you everything I had You made a fool out of me I thought we were in love You were never who you claimed to be [Cello and violin break] [Bridge] I'd been cheated on myself I knew how that kind of hurt could stay I thought I'd found a love worth trusting Then it all slipped away And when I thought about her husband I knew the pain he'd be going through I'd never meant to be part of that But I was, and I hated that truth [Chorus] I thought we were in love God, I wanted to believe You made me think your heart was mine While you were lying through your teeth I gave you everything I had You made a fool out of me I thought we were in love You were never who you claimed to be [Outro] Sometimes I still think about you Though I know I can't go back I still wonder how I missed it How I trusted what we had I thought we were in love....
