[Verse] He picks up the phone a whisper breaks through Three little words I love you I do His hands start to tremble His world turns blue [Prechorus] The air is heavy like a weightless lie He looks at her Tears in his eye [Chorus] Girl why would you do this to us why Was it a game or a lullaby You stitched the stars then tore the sky Girl why would you do this to us why [Verse 2] She stands in silence no words to defend Her eyes hold secrets she cannot amend He feels the crack where trust might end [Bridge] Was it the moon was it the night Was it something I missed in the fading light Did I love too much or not enough Girl why would you gamble on our love [Chorus] Girl why would you do this to us why Was it a game or a lullaby You stitched the stars then tore the sky Girl why would you do this to us why