
[Intro: Dissonant Rhodes clusters, off-kilter drums] [Verse 1: Voices trade lines; bass moves in odd meter] [Kindness] I gave because their pain was real. [Applause-Seeker] You hoped they’d say your name. [Appetite] I wanted comfort now. [Duty] I kept the old commitments safe. [Kindness] I thought I’d made their burden lighter. [Applause-Seeker] You wanted to be praised. [Appetite] I wanted one fast feeling. [Duty] I wanted no one let down. [Pre-Chorus: Guitars enter one by one] [Kindness] Both can be true. [Applause-Seeker] I hate that truth. [Appetite] I want relief. [Duty] I want the proof. [All] We each have something to defend And something we must own [Chorus: Full band; voices layered and overlapping] Cross-examine every motive Pull the easy answers apart A good deed can hold a hunger A bad choice doesn’t name a heart No clean witness, no pure motive No one voice explains it all Cross-examine every motive Let the whole self answer the call [Verse 2: Drums stutter; cello rises] I helped, and wanted recognition I promised, then concealed resentment I chose the rush, ignored the aftermath I knew the cost, delayed the reckoning I called my fear devotion I called my wanting fate I asked the others for their testimony Then argued with what they would state [Bridge: Sudden silence, then one voice] I did it I wanted it I can say both things I can name the choice Without naming myself beyond repair [Final Chorus: Heavy guitars, shouted doubles] No clean witness, no pure motive Still, the truth belongs to me Cross-examine every motive Then decide what I will be [Ending: Band hits in unison]

