[Verse 1] you turn your face like a locked-up door, boots in the hallway, then nothing more smoke in the curtains, heat in the wall, you don’t turn around when i start to call i got your name in my grinding teeth, got your laugh buried under my breath tell me, woman, what did i do to make you look at me like you knew? [Pre-Chorus] you said you needed air, you said you needed sky, but there ain’t a breath in this house tonight [Chorus] why do you have to leave me with the lights cut low and the room gone mean? why do you have to leave me with your shadow still on my damn cold sheet? why do you have to leave me when i’m holding on like a nailed-down sin? why do you have to leave me when i still feel you underneath my skin? [Verse 2] your perfume hangs like a warning bell, sweet as heaven, sharp as hell i taste the iron when i breathe too deep, i taste the iron when i breathe too deep, like coins on my tongue, like blood in my sleep you wrote your goodbye in a trembling hand, left it on the table by your wedding band but the paper lies, and the ink don’t tell how the night went quiet when you fell [Pre-Chorus] you swore i was a storm you couldn’t outrun, but you forgot, girl, i’m the one [Chorus] why do you have to leave me when the walls still shake from what we said? why do you have to leave me when your voice still rings in my hungry head? why do you have to leave me like a ghost that won’t forgive the night? why do you have to leave me when the deadbolt’s locked from the inside? [Bridge] in the dark where the floorboards talk… hush now… hush now… hush now… hush now… hear the river in the deadbolt… [Breakdown] you didn’t go you didn’t run you didn’t leave me i was the one [Verse 3] i keep saying “leave” like it’s clean and true, like you walked out light with nothing to prove but i felt the room change shape that night, heard your breath go thin in the failing light i didn’t lose you to some open road, didn’t watch you vanish like drifting smoke i kept you close where the cold stays true, where the earth holds tight, and it won’t let you [Pre-Chorus] so ask it again, let the question bleed, i’ll give you the answer you never need [Final Chorus] why do you have to leave me when i’m the hand that closed the door? why do you have to leave me when i put you where you can’t scream anymore? why do you have to leave me when your heartbeat stopped beneath my hands? why do you have to leave me when i made sure you never could?