
⸻ 🎵 “Don’t Mess With Interstate Trade” (Dormant Commerce Clause Song) Verse 1 Well the Constitution gave Congress the power to trade Across the states where the big rigs roll and goods get made But when Congress stays quiet and doesn’t say a word The Court still watches what the states have heard Pre-Chorus If a state makes a rule for the markets and roads We ask one question before it explodes Chorus Don’t mess with interstate trade That’s the Dormant Commerce rule we made If your law blocks out-of-state goods at the gate That law might seal its own fate Three tests the Court will use To see if your regulation loses Discrimination, balancing, or safety debate Don’t mess with interstate trade ⸻ Verse 2 – Discrimination Rule First thing we ask when a state draws a line Does it favor locals every single time? If it blocks outsiders just to help its own That kind of law gets overthrown Hook That’s discrimination, plain to see Almost always unconstitutional, usually Bridge Line Unless the state can prove one thing is true No other way will safely do (like Maine v. Taylor) ⸻ Chorus Don’t mess with interstate trade That’s the Dormant Commerce rule we made If your law blocks out-of-state goods at the gate That law might seal its own fate Three tests the Court will use To see if your regulation loses Discrimination, balancing, or safety debate Don’t mess with interstate trade ⸻ Verse 3 – Pike Balancing Test But if the law treats everyone the same And interstate trade isn’t its aim Then we balance the costs and benefits there And ask if the burden is fair Pike says: If the burden on commerce is clearly too great Compared to the benefits claimed by the state The Court will step in and invalidate (Pike v. Bruce Church) ⸻ Verse 4 – Highway Safety Cases Sometimes the state says “This rule keeps roads safe” But the Court still checks the burden we face If trucks must change just crossing a line That might be too much interference in time (like Southern Pacific and Kassel) ⸻ Final Chorus (memory chorus) Don’t mess with interstate trade Dormant Commerce Clause gets paid First ask: Does it discriminate? If yes, that law faces strict debate If neutral law is what we see Use Pike balancing carefully Burden high and benefits low? Then the Court will strike the law

