Pretty When I Sin (Remake) x Alibi (Etoille Mashup 2026)

+ Show full styles

[VERSE 1 – GUEST]
Lipstick like a warning sign
Hearts break when they cross my line
Silk dress, but the knife’s inside
Sweet smile, but I don’t play nice
You love the fire in my eyes
You swear you’re different from the lies
But baby I’ve been here before
Every king falls at my door

[VERSE 2 – ETOILLE]
Three AM, the city sleeps
Velvet shadows, tangled sheets
Your lipstick resting by the wine
We should probably get our stories right
You were at the opera, I was out of town
Funny how your earrings ended up lying around
You say you went to dinner, I say I stayed home
Better check our stories before somebody phones
(Spoken, teasing.)
Darling...
You hate the opera.
(Soft laugh.)
Details.

[PRE-CHORUS – GUEST / ETOILLE]
[GUEST]
They say I’m trouble in a red dress
A pretty little dark mess
But you still want the taste
[ETOILLE]
One little secret, two perfect smiles
We could keep them guessing for a while
Every little question, every little why
Just another reason to rehearse our lie
(Whisper.)
Ready?
Let's practice.

[CHORUS – GUEST]
I look pretty when I sin
When I let the chaos in
Angel face with villain skin
Baby, that’s the game I win
Say my name like a prayer
But you know I don’t play fair
Heaven tried to keep me in
But I look pretty when I sin

[CHORUS – ETOILLE]
You're my alibi, I'm your perfect lie
Two innocent faces in the morning light
Let them ask their questions, let them wonder why
Nobody tells a story better than you and I
You're my alibi, keep me by your side
Every little secret that we have to hide
They can have the truth they want to buy
But you know mine, and I know why
Alibi... (Alibi...)
You and I... (You and I...)
Such beautiful lies...

[VERSE 3 – ETOILLE / POP-RAP]
(Bouncing 808, ticking hi-hats.)
Tick-tock, wristwatch, quarter past three
You say you were home, but you were with me
Black dress, gold chain, lipstick on glass
Better make a story that'll actually last
Click-click, phone rings, somebody's calling
Quick-quick, darling, your excuses are falling
You were at a meeting, I was on a flight
Funny how we both disappeared last night
No names, no dates, no little clues
She's got her story, I've got mine too
One glance, one laugh, another mistake
How many excuses can two women make?
(Spoken exchange.)
"Business trip?"
"Too obvious."
"Charity dinner?"
"Much better."

[VERSE 4 – GUEST]
Midnight dripping from my heels
Every promise never real
You’re addicted to the thrill
Of a heart that loves to kill
Golden halo cracked in two
I don’t break — I break you
Every warning you ignore
Just makes you want me more

[BRIDGE – CLOCKWORK BREAKDOWN]
(Only ticking clock. Two intimate female voices.)
"So..."
"Where were you last night?"
"At home. Alone."
"And me?"
"At the opera."
(Pause.)
"Darling..."
"You were with me."
(Soft laughter.)
"I know."
(Close whisper.)
"That's why it's an alibi."
(Clock stops. Silence.)
[GUEST – sinister whisper]
Don’t call me your salvation
I’m the final temptation
You built your own damn cage
Now watch me walk away

[FINAL CHORUS – ALTERNATING FEMALE LEADS]
(Massive cinematic 808 drop, strings, layered harmonies.)
[GUEST]
I look pretty when I sin
When the darkness pulls me in
Halo falling from my skin
Guess the villain always wins
Say my name like a prayer
But you know I don’t play fair
Heaven tried to keep me in
But I look pretty when I sin
[ETOILLE]
You're my alibi, I'm your perfect lie
Two innocent faces in the morning light
Let them ask their questions, let them wonder why
Nobody tells a story better than you and I
Your story! (My story!)
My secret! (Your secret!)
Nobody knows! (Nobody knows!)
Alibi... (Alibi...)
You and I... (You and I...)
Such beautiful lies...

[OUTRO – BOTH, WHISPERED]
[ETOILLE]
Right.
One more time.
You were at the opera.
I was out of town.
(Pause.)
And we definitely...
Never saw each other.
(Soft laugh.)
Goodnight, darling.

4128/7500

[INTRO – ETOILLE / GUEST] (Ticking clock, vinyl hiss, dark piano, sliding 808. Two female voices.) [ETOILLE – whispered] So... Where were you tonight? (Soft laugh.) Careful, baby. Think before you answer. [GUEST – whispered] Shh… You thought I was the good girl, didn’t you? [VERSE 1 – GUEST] Lipstick like a warning sign Hearts break when they cross my line Silk dress, but the knife’s inside Sweet smile, but I don’t play nice You love the fire in my eyes You swear you’re different from the lies But baby I’ve been here before Every king falls at my door [VERSE 2 – ETOILLE] Three AM, the city sleeps Velvet shadows, tangled sheets Your lipstick resting by the wine We should probably get our stories right You were at the opera, I was out of town Funny how your earrings ended up lying around You say you went to dinner, I say I stayed home Better check our stories before somebody phones (Spoken, teasing.) Darling... You hate the opera. (Soft laugh.) Details. [PRE-CHORUS – GUEST / ETOILLE] [GUEST] They say I’m trouble in a red dress A pretty little dark mess But you still want the taste [ETOILLE] One little secret, two perfect smiles We could keep them guessing for a while Every little question, every little why Just another reason to rehearse our lie (Whisper.) Ready? Let's practice. [CHORUS – GUEST] I look pretty when I sin When I let the chaos in Angel face with villain skin Baby, that’s the game I win Say my name like a prayer But you know I don’t play fair Heaven tried to keep me in But I look pretty when I sin [CHORUS – ETOILLE] You're my alibi, I'm your perfect lie Two innocent faces in the morning light Let them ask their questions, let them wonder why Nobody tells a story better than you and I You're my alibi, keep me by your side Every little secret that we have to hide They can have the truth they want to buy But you know mine, and I know why Alibi... (Alibi...) You and I... (You and I...) Such beautiful lies... [VERSE 3 – ETOILLE / POP-RAP] (Bouncing 808, ticking hi-hats.) Tick-tock, wristwatch, quarter past three You say you were home, but you were with me Black dress, gold chain, lipstick on glass Better make a story that'll actually last Click-click, phone rings, somebody's calling Quick-quick, darling, your excuses are falling You were at a meeting, I was on a flight Funny how we both disappeared last night No names, no dates, no little clues She's got her story, I've got mine too One glance, one laugh, another mistake How many excuses can two women make? (Spoken exchange.) "Business trip?" "Too obvious." "Charity dinner?" "Much better." [VERSE 4 – GUEST] Midnight dripping from my heels Every promise never real You’re addicted to the thrill Of a heart that loves to kill Golden halo cracked in two I don’t break — I break you Every warning you ignore Just makes you want me more [BRIDGE – CLOCKWORK BREAKDOWN] (Only ticking clock. Two intimate female voices.) "So..." "Where were you last night?" "At home. Alone." "And me?" "At the opera." (Pause.) "Darling..." "You were with me." (Soft laughter.) "I know." (Close whisper.) "That's why it's an alibi." (Clock stops. Silence.) [GUEST – sinister whisper] Don’t call me your salvation I’m the final temptation You built your own damn cage Now watch me walk away [FINAL CHORUS – ALTERNATING FEMALE LEADS] (Massive cinematic 808 drop, strings, layered harmonies.) [GUEST] I look pretty when I sin When the darkness pulls me in Halo falling from my skin Guess the villain always wins Say my name like a prayer But you know I don’t play fair Heaven tried to keep me in But I look pretty when I sin [ETOILLE] You're my alibi, I'm your perfect lie Two innocent faces in the morning light Let them ask their questions, let them wonder why Nobody tells a story better than you and I Your story! (My story!) My secret! (Your secret!) Nobody knows! (Nobody knows!) Alibi... (Alibi...) You and I... (You and I...) Such beautiful lies... [OUTRO – BOTH, WHISPERED] [ETOILLE] Right. One more time. You were at the opera. I was out of town. (Pause.) And we definitely... Never saw each other. (Soft laugh.) Goodnight, darling.

0/500