[Verse 1, almost speaking] We split the records Sunday morning. You took Mingus, I took Monk. We saved the one we'd played to ruin till all the easy work was done. You touched the scratch at minute seven. “Can you even play this one?” [Chorus, soft syncopation] Keep the one that skips. The singer gets as far as kiss, kiss, kiss, and we can give the word as long as it can stand. Keep the one that skips. [Verse 2, brushes widen] You said you'd tried to get beyond it by weighing down the needle's arm. It played clean through one afternoon. The line was “kiss the boy goodbye.” How quietly we both went, “Ah.” [Bridge, bare voice] I wanted all our years together. I wanted you to take that job. I meant them both with equal fervor. You took the record when you left. [Final chorus, one low harmony] Keep the one that skips. Some days you'll hear it through. Sometimes a boy gets one more kiss, kiss, kiss from a much younger you. Keep the one that skips.