Song Cover Image

Ice Cream Before Dinner?!

[Verse 1] I walked in, the room was loud She had ice cream, she was spinning proud You said, “She’s been good, I thought it’s fine” But I’m stuck cleaning sugar from the blinds You laugh it off, that crooked grin While I’m the one reeling her back in We made plans, we had a way But you bend it all like it’s a game [Chorus] What were you thinking? Ice cream before dinner — no reason, no rhyme What were you thinking? Fries ain’t greens no matter the time You said you hit the pub for water But honey, that’s not how you father [Verse 2 ] She learned to toast with juice in hand Burps are now her marching band “Let her jump, she’s just a kid” But it’s your voice in the things she did But it’s your voice in the things she did You light her world — yeah, that’s true But you burn the rules we built in two You call it “fun,” I call it “tilt” Love can’t grow without the guilt [Chorus] What were you thinking? Candy before bed, glitter on the dog What were you thinking? A “tiny beer” — are we really fine with that? You’re her hero, her spark, her thrill But I’m the one who keeps her still [Bridge] I know your love is big, it shows But chaos grows in sugar’s glow And I’m not mad, I’m just worn thin Wishing you’d hold the line again [Final Chorus] What were you thinking? Ice cream before dinner like you didn’t see What were you thinking? KFC and bedtime at three I love your soul, I love your fight But some days… I just want you to get it right [Outro] Yeah… she smiled… Yeah… I know… But this love… takes more than show.