[Verse 1] It’s late and the rain’s comin' down I’m caught in a memory tonight That old tune is hauntin’ the silence Pullin’ your memory back into the light [Pre-Chorus] I don’t call, she don’t write But damn, I feel her on these nights [Chorus] So play that song again The one where the chords sound like the way we began The one she loved to dance to barefoot in the den Let the melody rewind the time back when— We were more than just a could’ve been Yeah, play that song again [Verse 2] The vinyl’s cracked but it’s honest Like us when we let down our guard She said forever so softly Now forever feels so far [Pre-Chorus] People think I'm back on track But the music still brings me back [Chorus] So play that song again The one where the lyrics feel just like her skin Tracing dreams across my skin like shifting sand Let the needle fall and let my heart pretend We’re still more than just a could’ve been Yeah, play that song again [Bridge] No, I don’t need her back I just need to hear that one track To carry me off somewhere Somewhere where we both still cared [Instrumental] [Final Chorus] So play that song again The one that sounds like home before the end Where her laughter lived and love didn’t have to mend I know it hurts, but let the record spin 'Cause tonight, I need to feel it then— Yeah, play that song again [Outro] Just one more time Then maybe I’ll be fine