[Verse 1] You left your blue mug by the kitchen sink A half-read paperback folded where you think I’d find it when the afternoon went quiet Your note said ā€œcall me,ā€ but you never tried it I took the long way past the corner store Where we used to split one soda into four The cashier asked if you were coming later I said ā€œprobably,ā€ and watched the paper waiter [Pre-Chorus] I keep making room beside me Like your coat is still there Some habits don’t ask permission They just settle in the air [Chorus] If you come back, don’t knock too hard I’m still learning how to leave the door ajar We can talk where the old paint peels Tell me what was true and what you couldn’t feel If you come back, I won’t pretend We were easy, we were certain, we were built to never bend But I saved your name inside my phone Somewhere between letting go and being alone [Verse 2] I saw your sister at the laundromat She said you moved, but didn’t say where at I folded shirts beneath the buzzing ceiling Trying to guess what leaving had been meaning My friends say time will make it make sense Like a receipt can show me where the money went I laugh along, then miss the train at seven Walk home with your silence in my headphones [Pre-Chorus] I keep making room beside me Though I know you’re not there Some promises lose their shape Before they disappear [Chorus] If you come back, don’t knock too hard I’m still learning how to leave the door ajar We can talk where the old paint peels Tell me what was true and what you couldn’t feel If you come back, I won’t pretend We were easy, we were certain, we were built to never bend But I saved your name inside my phone Somewhere between letting go and being alone [Bridge] Maybe I wanted an answer Maybe you wanted escape Maybe the truth is a hallway Neither of us knew how to face I won’t turn the clock backward I won’t call it a mistake Just leave the light in the window For whatever our hearts can remake [Final Chorus] If you come back, don’t knock too hard I’m still learning how to leave the door ajar We can talk where the old paint peels Tell me what was true and what you couldn’t feel If you come back, I won’t pretend But I can meet you somewhere past the bitter end I saved your name, then let it go Somewhere between the person I was and the person I now know [Outro] The blue mug’s gone from the kitchen sink The book is closed, but I still stop to think If you come back, I’ll hear you through the hall And if you don’t, I’ll be alright after all