I saw you at the back By the second bar Same black dress Same little scar You laughed at something He leaned in too I knew that look The one I have When I look at you And my mind went back To when I was with you But now… He’s got your hand Like he knows what I know You carved “yours forever” When we were fifteen Now you’re beside him And I’m under that tree Your name next to mine Cut too deep for me Who’s that guy with you? You should be mine You should be mine You wrote it on the tree When we were fifteen You should be mine You should be mine So who’s that guy with you? You should be mine (mine, mine) Who’s that guy with you? (with you) You saw me looking From the other side He said something funny You forgot to smile You touched your necklace Then you touched your glass Like you were trying Not to look back He pulled you closer You let him try But you said my name With only your eyes He’s got your hand But I know what you know You can turn your face But your eyes won’t go Your name next to mine Cut too deep for me And I’m right back there Under that tree Who’s that guy with you? You should be mine You should be mine You wrote it on the tree When we were fifteen You should be mine You should be mine So who’s that guy with you? I don’t hate him I hate that he can Stand where I stood Holding your hand If he loves you I won’t make a scene But you left my name Carved in that tree Who’s that guy with you? You should be mine You should be mine You wrote it on the tree When we were fifteen You should be mine You should be mine So who’s that guy with you? You should be mine (mine) Who’s that guy with you?