Song Cover Image

You Already Know It

V6

[INTRO — 1:38 A.M. / rain / glasses / muffled conversation] Bartender said last call. I wasn’t ready to go home. That’s when she sat down. Black coat. Long hair. Maybe forty-something. Beautiful… But tired. Like she’d lived through something. WOMAN: You look like somebody who doesn’t wanna go home. MAN: You look like somebody who asks too many questions. WOMAN: Maybe. MAN: You always talk to strangers? WOMAN: Only the ones who look lonely. [BEAT DROPS] [VERSE 1] She smiled. Something about her felt familiar. Couldn’t explain why. Bartender wiping glasses while I’m talking to this stranger about the shit I keep inside. She asked about my family. Asked about my father. Asked why every time she mentioned love I changed the subject harder. MAN: Damn, lady. You a therapist? WOMAN: No. MAN: Then how the hell you reading me? WOMAN: People aren’t that complicated when you actually listen. MAN: Maybe. WOMAN: What’s hurting you? MAN: You really wanna know? WOMAN: I wouldn’t have asked. [VERSE 2 — STORY GETS PERSONAL] So I told her. About the people that I buried. About relationships that died while both of us were still breathing. Told her sometimes I drive around because I hate an empty house. How everybody thinks I’m strong because they never hear the doubts. How some mornings I wake up angry that the world kept fucking moving. People laughing. People working. People loving. People choosing. Like the universe didn’t notice everything I fucking lost. She looked down at her hands and said— WOMAN: It noticed. MAN: What? WOMAN: Nothing. Keep going. [HOOK — HAUNTING FEMALE SAMPLE] Stranger at the end of the bar, tell me why you know my scars. Why you looking through my eyes like you’ve already seen inside? I don’t know your name. You don’t know mine. But something about you tonight feels like I’ve known you my whole damn life. [VERSE 3 — WOMAN’S STORY] Eventually I asked: MAN: What about you? WOMAN: What about me? MAN: I’ve been talking for an hour. Your turn. She laughed. Not happy. More like remembering something. WOMAN: I had somebody once. Loved him more than myself. Spent years trying to save him when he wouldn’t save himself. He carried so much anger. Thought pain made him strong. Every time somebody loved him, he’d find a reason they were wrong. MAN: What happened? WOMAN: I lost him. MAN: He die? WOMAN: Depends what you mean by die. [BEAT STUTTERS] MAN: That’s a strange answer. WOMAN: It’s a strange world. [VERSE 4 — UNEASINESS BUILDS] Then she started saying things that made my stomach turn. Little pieces of my history she had no way to learn. WOMAN: You still keep that picture? MAN: What picture? She froze. WOMAN: Never mind. MAN: No. What picture? WOMAN: I shouldn’t have said that. MAN: Lady… Who the fuck are you? She looked toward the door. WOMAN: It’s getting late. MAN: Answer me. WOMAN: Some answers hurt worse than questions. MAN: What does that mean? WOMAN: It means… You need to stop blaming yourself. [TOTAL SILENCE] MAN: For what? But she was already standing. WOMAN: I need to go. MAN: Wait. At least tell me your name. She looked at me. And smiled. WOMAN: You already know it. [BEAT CUTS] [VERSE 5 — THE DISAPPEARANCE] She walked toward the hallway. I threw twenty on the counter. Followed maybe five seconds later— Nothing. Bathroom door open. Back exit locked. No woman. I walked back confused. MAN: Hey. BARTENDER: What’s up? MAN: Where’d she go? BARTENDER: Who? Here we fucking go. MAN: The woman! Black coat. Sitting right there! BARTENDER: Man… Nobody’s been sitting there. MAN: Bullshit. You’ve been serving us all night. BARTENDER: Serving us? I’ve poured you three drinks. That’s it. [SILENCE] MAN: … She was right fucking there. BARTENDER: You okay? MAN: No. Apparently not. [BEAT RETURNS — SAMPLE REVERSED] [VERSE 6 — THE CLUE] Bartender starts cleaning. I’m staring at that stool. Trying to convince myself I’m tired, drunk or losing it. Then he stops. BARTENDER: Wait. MAN: What? He reaches underneath the stool. BARTENDER: This yours? A photograph. Old. Edges bent. I grabbed it. And every hair on my body stood up. There she was. Same eyes. Same smile. Same woman from the bar. Standing beside a younger man. But the photograph looked older than either one of us should be. MAN: Where’d you get this? BARTENDER: It was under the chair. I flipped it over. Writing on the back. Three words. “Please forgive me.” [NO DRUMS] Underneath… A date. Twenty-seven years ago. MAN: … What the fuck? [FINAL VERSE — NO ANSWER GIVEN] I ran outside. Empty street. Rain coming down. Called out: MAN: HEY! Nothing. Looked at the picture again. That’s when I noticed something I hadn’t seen before. The man standing beside her… had my eyes. Not looked like me. Not kinda. My fucking eyes. And around his neck— the same chain I inherited when I was twen