Song Cover Image

Song 19 — What Judgment May Be Given?

V6

(Verse 1 — Lady Kati Evans, female lead) They brought a man before the bench With silver in a sack. A Merchant said, “He took my coin. I want my money back.” A voice behind him called for chains. Another shouted, “Thief!” I asked the guard to still the room And let the Merchant speak. (Verse 2 — Merchant, male lead) “I left that purse beside my books And turned to fetch a light. When I came back, the purse was gone. This man had been in sight. They found him down beside the quay With silver of his own. I ask the court to hear my claim And have my losses known.” (Chorus — mixed voices) What judgment may be given? What does the evidence show? What law applies within these walls? What must the court still know? Before the order leaves the bench, Before the guards are sent, Name the act the proof establishes, Then the lawful punishment. (Verse 3 — Accused Man, male lead) “I carried cargo from a boat And earned that silver there. The captain paid me at the quay. His clerk can tell you where. I stood beside the Merchant’s stall, But others passed there too. Go ask the men who paid my wage Before you say you’re through.” (Verse 4 — Lady Kati Evans, female lead) I sent for those who knew the wage And asked about the purse. What marks were on the missing coin? Who’d seen it taken first? The clerk arrived with names and sums, The captain came as well. We heard their answers separately, With time for each to tell. (Chorus — mixed voices) What judgment may be given? What does the evidence show? What law applies within these walls? What must the court still know? Before the order leaves the bench, Before the guards are sent, Name the act the proof establishes, Then the lawful punishment. (Bridge — Lady Kati Evans, female lead, quietly) Some judgments take a purse of coin, Some send a man away. Some take his freedom or his life. The words have weight to bear. Each city keeps its governing law, Each office has its bounds. Read the charge and hear the proof Before the sentence sounds. (Final verse — Lady Kati Evans, female lead) The wages matched the clerk’s account. The missing purse stayed lost. The Merchant’s grief was plain enough. He still must bear that cost. But theft by this man stood unproved. I ordered his release, And kept the record of the claim For further word from the streets. (Final chorus — mixed voices, restrained) What judgment may be given? What does the evidence show? What law applies within these walls? What must the court still know? Let the findings guide the order, Keep its lawful limits clear. For the sentence spoken from the bench Will reach beyond us here.