[Verse 1] I have carried so much quietly So you would not have to know What it feels like to grow up cold In a house that never felt like home I tried to build the softer walls Tried to keep the monsters out But somehow when the thunder comes Iโ€™m the one you blame somehow [Pre-Chorus] And I know I wasnโ€™t perfect God knows Iโ€™ve had my days But every scar I never showed you Was a war I fought to change [Chorus] How did I become The villain in your eyes? When all I ever wanted Was to keep you safe inside I loved you past the breaking Loved you louder than my pride But somehow Iโ€™m the shadow Standing in your light If you could see my heart Youโ€™d know it bleeds for you I was never trying to hurt you I was trying to get us through How did I become The villain in your eyes? When loving you has been The purpose of my life [Verse 2] I know my voice had edges When I was young and scared I know there were heavy moments I wish I could repair But I gave you what I never had A hand that stayed, a door that held A love that didnโ€™t walk away Even when I failed myself I kept the darkest things from you The ghosts that followed me I stood between you and the storm The best way I knew how to be [Pre-Chorus] And maybe you remember Every place where I fell short But I hope one day youโ€™ll see me As more than what I got wrong [Chorus] How did I become The villain in your eyes? When all I ever wanted Was to keep you safe inside I loved you past the breaking Loved you louder than my pride But somehow Iโ€™m the shadow Standing in your light If you could see my heart Youโ€™d know it bleeds for you I was never trying to hurt you I was trying to get us through How did I become The villain in your eyes? When loving you has been The purpose of my life [Bridge] I am not asking you to forget I am not asking you to lie I just wish you knew the difference Between my wounds and my design I was learning while I loved you I was healing while I held Trying not to pass the fire From the hell where I had dwelled And I am sorry for the moments When my pain got in the room But donโ€™t mistake my broken places For a lack of love for you [Final Chorus] How did I become The villain in your eyes? When I would have broken every bone To give you better skies I loved you in the chaos Loved you through the sleepless nights Loved you when I had no map And still chose to fight If you could see my heart Youโ€™d know the aching truth Every better part of me Was built from loving you How did I become The villain in your eyes? When loving you has been The purpose of my life [Outro] Maybe one day youโ€™ll see me Not as perfect, not as right Just someone who loved you deeply And was fighting for the light