[Verse 1] You walk in with your shoulders back, Acting like you own the room, Talking ’bout the girls you like, But you keep watching what I do. I catch you staring at my face, Then you suddenly check your phone, Boy, you’re not as slick as you think, And you know I know. You say, “You’re pretty.” I say, “I know.” You say, “Don’t get cocky.” I say, “Too late, though.” [Pre-Chorus] You keep saying, “I’m straight,” Like you’re trying to convince me, You keep saying, “Back up,” But you never really leave me. [Chorus] Try me!! You keep saying that you won’t, Try me!! But you’re acting like you might. You can tell me you’re straight Till the morning turns to night, But you can’t tell your eyes To stop looking at mine. Try me!! Come on, say it one more time. “I don’t like pretty boys.” Baby, that’s a pretty good lie. You don’t have to prove a thing, You don’t have to change your mind— I’m just having fun with you. Try me!! [Verse 2] I fix my hair, you roll your eyes, I smile, you look away, I put my jacket on real slow, And suddenly you got nothing to say. You tell your friends I’m annoying, They start laughing at you, ‘Cause apparently they noticed What I’ve already knew. “Don’t flirt with me.” “Who says I’m flirting?” “That’s exactly what you’re doing.” “Maybe you’re just nervous.” [Pre-Chorus] You keep saying, “I’m straight,” Like it’s part of your introduction, But somehow every conversation Turns into our little confrontation. [Chorus] Try me!! You keep saying that you won’t, Try me!! But you’re acting like you might. You can tell me you’re straight Till the morning turns to night, But you can’t tell your eyes To stop looking at mine. Try me!! Come on, say it one more time. “I don’t like pretty boys.” Baby, that’s a pretty good lie. You don’t have to prove a thing, You don’t have to change your mind— I’m just having fun with you. Try me!! [Verse 3] You ask me who I’m texting, I say, “Why do you care?” You say, “I don’t.” Then you keep standing there. You ask where I’m going, I say, “Why? You wanna come?” You say, “Absolutely not.” Then you ask what time I’m done. You make it way too obvious, But I’ll never call you out, I’ll just keep smiling innocently And let you figure it out. You’re trying so hard to win, I’m barely trying at all, And somehow every time I tease you, You’re the first one to call. [Breakdown] “Stop smiling.” Why? “Stop looking at me.” Make me. “You’re ridiculous.” Thank you. “You know exactly what you’re doing.” Finally, you noticed. [Pre-Chorus 2] I’m not trying to change you, I’m not trying to make you choose, I’m just throwing little sparks And watching what you do. You can keep your label, You can keep your pride, But if you’re really unaffected, Why are you still by my side? [Chorus] Try me!! You keep saying that you won’t, Try me!! But you’re acting like you might. You can tell me you’re straight Till the morning turns to night, But you can’t tell your eyes To stop looking at mine. Try me!! Come on, say it one more time. “I don’t like pretty boys.” Baby, that’s a pretty good lie. You don’t have to prove a thing, You don’t have to change your mind— I’m just having fun with you. Try me!! [Bridge] Maybe I’m your biggest headache, Maybe I’m your favorite one. Maybe you just like the arguing, Maybe you like having fun. Maybe nothing’s gonna happen, Maybe this is where it ends, Maybe I’m just the pretty boy Who somehow became your friend. And that’s okay, I won’t push you. I’ll just grin and let you be. But every time you say, “Don’t tease me,” You make it way too easy. [Quiet Pre-Chorus] So tell me I’m annoying. Tell me I’m a mess. Tell me I’m too pretty And you’re not impressed. Tell me you’re straight. Tell me you’re certain. Tell me you don’t care— Then why’d you smile When I walked over there? [Final Chorus] TRY ME!! You keep saying that you won’t! TRY ME!! Now you’re laughing when you shout! You can tell me you’re straight, You can say it loud, But I’m not asking you to figure yourself out. TRY ME!! Come on, run your mouth again! “Pretty boys aren’t my type.” Then why’d you call me your friend? You don’t have to prove a thing, You don’t have to cross a line, I’ll keep teasing you forever Just to see that stupid smile. [Outro] You said, “I’m straight.” I said, “Okay.” You said, “Stop teasing me.” I said, “Maybe someday.”
