
[Intro] [Instrumental, 4 bars] [Verse 1] You found the one they never stock I’d mentioned once to you I hadn’t thought you’d held onto A thing I barely knew You watched me work the paper loose And waited for my face I asked how much, then offered you A meal at any place You hadn’t finished telling me How far you’d gone that day Before I started making plans To give as much away [Pre-Chorus] You almost thought I didn’t like The thing you’d found for me I hadn’t even put it down And still you couldn’t see [Chorus] You shouldn’t have, I said But I’m so glad you did I wish you’d seen how much I loved The part of me I hid You wanted me to have a thing I wouldn’t get myself I wanted you to take it back— The thanks, not something else [Verse 2] I know the trick of getting there Before the bill arrives I like to end the argument Before the other tries I’ve told you, “You don’t owe a thing” And meant it every time But hearing you say that to me Does something to my pride You told me where you’d come across The last one they had left I thought about your birthday while You told me all the rest [Pre-Chorus] You shouldn’t have to reassure The person getting gifts I made you work to give me one Then wondered what I missed [Chorus] You shouldn’t have, I said But I’m so glad you did I wish you’d seen how much I loved The part of me I hid You wanted me to have a thing I wouldn’t get myself I wanted you to take it back— The thanks, not something else [Instrumental Break] [Bridge] I had the money and the time To get it on my own But you were somewhere without me And thought of me alone That’s what I haven’t figured out A fair exchange for yet You gave me something I could buy And something I can’t get [Final Chorus] You shouldn’t have, I said Like I wished you hadn’t tried When I wanted you to know me Just that well, but kept my pride You wanted me to have a thing I wouldn’t get myself I’ve moved it three times since you left To see it better on the shelf [Outro] I kept the little note you wrote And read it when you’d gone I sent a picture: “Look, it fits” Then typed, “Next time it’s on me” And left that last bit unsent

